Budget Friendly Wedding Cake – Guess what?!? There can be a solution to the expensive wedding cake. Don’t get me wrong…a wedding cake can be a great thing to spend money on. But, if you are having a small wedding or wedding where dessert is included in your tasting menu, then I’m going to tell you how you can have your cake and eat it too!

Why write this piece of advice about a budget friendly wedding cake?

I thought about writing this blog when I had a bride tell me about her wedding cake experience.  She had a very small wedding – her fiancé, and 2 friends. She wasn’t really on a budget – she was smart with her spending. She paid extra for a wedding arch, wanted dinner at a nice restaurant and to have a few days honeymooning in Cambria. I had asked her about her wedding cake and she laughed. Her friend then said, “We actually got it from Vons and you should see it.” I was a little unsure what to say next – was this a good you should see it or a not good you should see it.  Then, her friend went on to say…it looks amazing!  Ok…I could breathe!  

See, here’s how it went –  she wasn’t really too excited to spend $200 for a cake from the restaurant or even $85 from a local bakery.  I’d have to agree with her, since her wedding was only her fiancé and 2 guests.  I’d spend that money on something else for the wedding.  At Vons she spent $10 for a small cake!  

That made me think, why not let couples know about selecting a cake from the grocery store?  Could a store bought wedding cake be a budget friendly wedding cake that can be as beautiful and tasty as one from a private bakery? You have something to cut and something to throw in each other’s face, you also have something for photos.

Also, many restaurants for reception locations have dessert included in their meal prices. Because of this, many couples don’t want to serve their guests boring old wedding cake. At the last wedding I went to, they had salted caramel cookies and churros and chocolate sauce to dip. 

I did purchase my wedding cake from a private bakery. It was delicious and very pretty!  The sad part was that my photographer didn’t even get a great photo of the cake and monthly later the bakery went out of business because the owner retired. So, I can’t really remember what it looked like and I can’t even have a slice of cake from the bakery!  My wedding was a little larger than just 2 guests so it went with the budget to have a wedding cake.  

Cost of a store bought cake 

The cost of a wedding cake is around $6 per person from a private bakery. Even the smallest size 8 inch wedding cake, that feeds 24 people, costs around $150 for that cake.  The private bakeries sometimes require you have a cake stand or rent one from them to put your cake on.  The rentals are around $25 – $75 and many times they require you bring the rental back to them.

I went to our local Albertson’s and find out this information about their cakes:

Our local  Albertson’s charges $17 for an 8 inch cake. That’s less than $1 per slice. They also have a mini cake that is 6 inches for $7.

You could purchase a couple’s cake for the two of you and then add on a sheet cake for your guests.  At some restaurant we work with for receptions, their dinners come with a dessert. So, the cake would really only be for the two of you. 

They have also have 1/2 sheet and 1/4 sheet cakes than can be sliced and offered to guests. 

The flavors of the cake are vanilla, chocolate, marble and red velvet.  Frosting can be cream cheese, butter cream or chocolate whipped cream.  

Fillings like chocolate, lemon, and strawberry can be added to the cake also.

The bakery needs 24 hour notice to make your cake.  For some local bakeries 

Here’s the challenge

Fast forward a few months and a bride asked me, “Do you really need a wedding cake?” So, could I come up with a budget friendly wedding cake? My answer was yes, you need something to cut, but let me see if I can put something together for you.

Here’s the challenge – Can I make a store bought cake look like a wedding bakery cake?  

One couple took me up on this offer! And, I think the store bought cake looked pretty awesome!

I think decorations can make anything look better.  So, I took a simple cake and added a little pizazz to it.  

For the couple’s cake above, I bought the cake topper from Rawkrft , a store on Etsy and got a few extra flowers from the florist.  I loved the cake topper!! It was perfectly packaged in a wood case that fit the topper perfectly. The part that goes into the cake was long enough so you could see the topper and still have room for flowers. The cake topper is made in California, so it shipped really fast.  For the flowers, they were just a few springs that were extra from the florist and the greenery came from their table flowers. But, if you really wanted, you could take a few flowers and greenery off your bouquet.  I added the flowers on myself, which many times is easy enough for the bride or a friend or family member to do.

For this cake, the gold “plate” came with the cake…added extra bonus for a grocery store cake lol. 

I’m not sure anyone would have guested that this cake was $7 from Vons, had a $14 topper and free wedding flowers on it. It was a $21 wedding cake. I’d have to say it was a beautiful, budget friendly wedding cake.

By Natalie Jones February 27, 2025
Here’s why you should have a small wedding in Pismo Beach Small weddings are the way to go these days! We aren’t just saying that because small weddings have been our thing since we started our business back in 2015. A small wedding can have the same parts of a large wedding - unforgettable moments, celebration with friends and family and the start of the rest of your life together. But, small wedding have a few more benefits like - less stress, less more, and more of the two of you and what you want for your wedding! We love the scenery of the Central Coast for small weddings. There are million dollar views - from your toes in the sand at one of the beach locations, to overlooking the ocean, to shaded eucalyptus trees, and jagged cliff sides. Small weddings are our favorite because the couple is free to focus on the most important things, like having their day, their way, spending the day with the people who truly matter, and having an amazing day packed with lasting memories. What Is Driving the Trend Toward Smaller Weddings? Several factors are behind the increasing trend of smaller weddings. Modern couples are redefining what it means to celebrate love, and in most cases, they focus on quality over quantity. Small weddings have become for popular and couples embrace fewer guests and find the beauty of intimate gatherings. Changing societal norms and the desire for unique, personalized experiences also make smaller weddings an attractive option. How Do Small Weddings Create More Meaningful Connections? Small weddings foster more meaningful connections by allowing couples to spend quality time with each guest, creating an intimate and personal atmosphere. With fewer attendees, conversations feel more genuine, and guests feel truly valued and appreciated. Some couples will have a few day long celebration for their wedding - starting a few days before the wedding with wine tasting or seeing the sites of the Central Coast, then relax on the beach the next day. After some fun in the sun, it's wedding day. The day will end with a group dinner or casual private reception. Then, the guests will leave and the couple has a few more days to celebrate their honeymoon in Pismo Beach or other beach location. This setting also encourages deeper interactions, making it easier to share special moments, heartfelt toasts, and personal stories. Without the hustle and chaos of a large event, couples and their loved ones can be fully present, strengthening bonds and making the celebration even more memorable. How Does a Smaller Guest List Reduce Wedding Stress? Planning a wedding can be quite challenging. It is easier for couples to plan their weddings with smaller guest lists, as this dramatically lowers their prospects of worrying. Incorporating fewer guests into a wedding means that there are fewer logistical elements to take care of, such as catering, seating arrangements, accommodations, and more people to please. This way, couples can spend more time and energy making their special day more unique instead of fretting over accommodating numerous people. A more personal gathering helps create a homely and calming vibe, giving the couple a chance to make the most of each interaction with their guests. Most importantly, a smaller guest number means that there would be fewer changes needed at the last minute, which translates to lower expenditure and costs. Hence, all attendees, coupled with the couple, can fully enjoy themselves without feeling the pressure of the wedding arrangements. What Are the Financial Benefits of Hosting a Small Wedding? Hosting a small wedding can be a cost-effective choice, offering couples the chance to allocate their budget more intentionally. With fewer guests, expenses for catering, venue size, and decor are reduced, freeing up funds for other priorities such as an unforgettable honeymoon or investing in a dream home. This financial flexibility allows couples to create a celebration that reflects their values and vision without overspending. Celebrate your love story with us! Small weddings are more than just a trend—they represent a shift in how couples approach one of the most important days of their lives. By focusing on intimacy, meaningful connections, and thoughtful planning, small weddings offer a unique and heartfelt way to celebrate love. For couples looking to create a stunning and intimate wedding experience, Coastal California Weddings is your simple and stress-free way to plan your wedding. We provide expert guidance and inspiration.
February 1, 2025
Not sure what to wear to a small wedding? We've got some tips on how to dress for a small wedding. Let us plan your small wedding in Pismo Beach.
January 30, 2025
Celebrate your wedding in Cambria! Come have your elopement or small wedding in Cambria. This wedding location overlooks the ocean, have a pretty tree grove and access to the beach. Let us plan your wedding in Cambria!
Show More
Share by: